The Genetic Engineering Information Bulletin: an independent, widely sourced digest of information relevant to the genetic engineering (GE) debate  
 
Home
  GE Info Bulletins  
   
  Return to Bulletin 53  
  Support  
 
No. 53 May/June 2007


GE products skip labelling
By DEBBIE JAMIESON - The Press (Christchurch)
Monday, 4 June 2007


A large number of common food products sold in supermarkets contain genetically engineered (GE) ingredients the consumer does not know about, food labelling critics say.

Food products containing GE protein and DNA must be labelled under Food Standards Authority Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) rules.
But Steve Abel, the researcher for the latest edition of the Greenpeace GE-Free Food Guide, says most GE products slip through various labelling loopholes.
About 30 strains of ingredients, such as corn, soybeans, canola oil and cottonseed oil, known to be genetically engineered but considered safe, were exempt from labelling, he said.
Similarly, food products that were highly processed, to the point that GE protein and DNA could not be detected, also escaped the labelling rules.

"We think the laws are weak. They're not informative enough for people," Abel said.
"They're based on an idea that there's no solid proof as far as the food-safety authority is concerned that GE is harmful.
"Therefore, our food safety organisation does not inform the public, who don't want to consume GE products."
Greenpeace had only been able to identify a tiny number of imported products that carried GE labelling as required by law, Abel said.
They were: Stagg Chilli Chunky Beef and Stagg Vegetable Garden Four-Bean Chilli from the United States and ProNutro, a maize-based cereal imported from South Africa.
Others, including an imported children's sweet and an imported energy bar, were also being assessed for this year's edition of the guide.
FSANZ New Zealand acting general manager Leigh Henderson said the rules, which came into place in 2002, ensured that if a food was not safe to eat it would not be approved.
Requiring every item that included highly processed GE products to be labelled was very difficult, she said.
"And it doesn't actually tell consumers anything more because the product is identical to others."
In Europe, food producers were required to trace ingredients and that imposed a huge cost on customers, she said.
"We have one of the most rigorous processes for the regulation of biotechnology products in the world," she said.
Green Party safe food spokeswoman Sue Kedgley attempted to introduce a bill changing the labelling rules last year but it was lost when both Labour and National opposed it.
"As far as I'm concerned it's an absolutely basic consumers' right to know what's in the food they eat," Kedgley said..
Abel said many food companies wanting to avoid labelling requirements had removed some products and ingredients from their range and the majority of companies now ranked in the highest category under the Greenpeace GE Free Food Guide.
Nestle, Cadbury, Stagg and ProNutro were in the red category - those which used GE products or had inadequate safeguards in place to guard against inadvertent GE exposure in food production.
Ernest Adams and Bluebird were in the orange or second tier of companies, which were in the process of removing GE ingredients from their food lines.
Pams, Whittakers chocolate, Sanitarium and Heinz Watties were green companies, which did not use GE at any stage in the production of their food, Abel said.

Web Link: http://www.stuff.co.nz/4083013a13.html

Note that direct links to the source are provided wherever possible. Otherwise, a link to a web-posted copy on a 3rd party site is given.
Sometimes these links will expire, so the above archived copy will be the only reference.

** NOTICE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed for research and educational purposes only. **

 

   
 
 

From The GE Information Service
The items in this bulletin are from articles which remain the copyright of the original owners. The material is published here for educational and public interest use only.


Hard copies of the Bulletin are available.
Single issues can be purchased for $5. You can also take out an annual subscription, covering a minimum of 10 issues, for $35.


The GE Information Bulletin is a project of the GE Information Service. It presents a regular digest of significant information from an international range of sources.
We rely on donations, grants and sponsorship. Please support our work to promote informed debate regarding the responsible use of genetic engineering.
Supporters have no editorial influence.

 


The GE Information Service
PO Box 78121, Grey Lynn
Auckland, New Zealand

Editor:
Stuart Sontier
Email:
editor@GEinfo.org.nz